The BEST mascara ever. Super smooth, lengthening, perfect dark coloring, and scentless. This mascara makes my lashes long, defined, separated, thick, and absolutely perfect. This mascara does not flake, it does not run when you go out in the rain, and it takes more than 2 month before it dries out (and I apply it daily!). The absolute best!

Wow amazing mascara -- brightens your eyes lengthens lashes have 1 hooded eye & it makes it pop -- I bought this during July Prime Sale I've received a lot of compliments and what mascara is that? not expensive -- pictures below no mascara /1eye /both eyes

I have tried innumerable 'waterproof' eyeliners from many cosmetics lines, this one actually works! I swim an hour every morning and I always ended up with raccoon eyes afterwards - no matter how much primer i used or setting spray. I did use Maybelline Color Tattoo in matte black to set it - looked perfect after swimming - even with me wiping water off my face! So thankful for the reviews here that helped me find a perfect eye liner for me.

As the title states, I love this eyeliner and it's my go-to product in that department. The tip is very fine for precise application and makes winged eyeliner a breeze. I like to make a tiny wing usually. The eyeliner dries pretty quickly as well and is smudge resistant. When I wear it all day it still looks fine but definitely starts to flake the smallest bit (which I don't mind).My biggest and only complaint about this product is when it starts to leak from the tip. Sometimes it forms a bubble which I carefully pop to not get it everywhere. I think they can work on the design to fix that issue, besides that, the eyeliner is great.

I mean what can I say about these that you don't already know...they're the BEST liquid liners in the game! I will splurge on high end products, especially when they're worth it. I used to use the Stila black liquid liner, I used it for years but then I noticed that the formula had changed and it wasn't as long wearing, vibrant, and smudge proof as it was previously. At $24 a pen it had better be darn good eyeliner! So I went on the hunt for another eyeliner that would live up to my expectations. I bought this at Wal-Mart when I was broke and figured it would get me through till payday when I had some more expensive brands already eyeballed out to buy... I've never bought another kind since! They're BETTER than Stila was before. It's matte, waterproof, BUILDABLE! One of the only brands of liquid liner I've come across (and I've come across MANY...) that layers well on top of itself. And I always have to do this because I always make one eye perfect and the other eye is inferior so I have to increase the wingspan, back and forth, until I look like Amy Winehouse. What I'm TRYING to say it's forgiving of human error. Lots of errors. The texture is PERFECT, if you're a minimalist and enjoy a lil' baby wing, it's perfectly black (not opaque at all) with one swipe. The tip allows you a tremendous amount of control, you can have the THINNEST line, or go as dramatic and bold as your creativity allows without worry of taking off the bottom layer if you have to do corrections. I may spend $53 on my foundation, but NYX has the market on liquid liner. If you're buying high end, WHY?? This is better for literally $10 a pen! Stockpile! Lord knows I am! JUST DON'T BUY THEM ALL!

I absolutely live with eyeliner on every single moment of the day. However, I have very oily eyelids and majority of eyeliners fail to last or stay put on my lids. So I require a very waterproof and smudgeproof formula to at least look good majority of the day before my oils decide to ruin it.My preferences for my eyeliners are a opaque black with a brush tip. As opaque and fluid felt tip eyeliners are, they are hard to control around my hooded eyes and sometimes end up becoming dried out even though I've only used the eyeliner a couple times.I've compared this NYX eyeliner against some of my favorites or some well known brands: Maybelline's Hyper Easy, MACQUEEN's Waterproof, EM Cosmetic's Illustrative, Heroine Make Smooth Liquid, Eyeko Black Magic, and KVD's Tattoo Liner.I put each of these up against 4 tests, which I've illustrated in my pictures. Maybelline's new eyeliner held up moderately well, and it's the only formula I've ever found to dry down matte and be this resistant. Of course, my favorite Asian eyeliners from MACQUEEN and Heroine Make are super waterproof and budget roof. Eyeko is also a favorite Asian brand that lasts moderately well. EM Cosmetics did not claim to be waterproof, just resistant, so I've allowed that to slide. I've never liked KVD's formula for my lids, so I'm not surprised that it didn't last.In comparison to those, NYX's formula isn't horrible and would work beautifully for most people, but it definitely can't last through my mighty eyelids. HOWEVER, I absolutely love how opaque the formula is in one swipe and how fluid and even it is. Makes it really easy to do graphic liners! It is also great for creating quick and easy wings (with a precise hand of course since it's so pigmented).I am going to continue using this with a primer or powder because I am enjoying the pigment! If you don't have crazy oily eyelids and would love a dark and even application with a brush tip eyeliner, I would highly recommend this eyeliner! And even if you do have lids like me, I'm sure one could make it work with some preparation!